Finding affordable car insurance in New York City can be a challenge with high rates typical for the area. By comparing some top providers in NYC, you can identify the best value policy for your needs. 

We gathered sample quotes and reviews for the top 5 auto insurers in New York City – Geico, Progressive, Allstate, State Farm, and MetLife. Read on to see how they compare based on cost, coverage, claims satisfaction, and more.

Section 1 – Cost Comparison  

We obtained sample quotes for three driver profiles to compare average rates. Progressive offered the lowest premiums among top insurers in NYC, followed by Geico. Allstate was the most expensive option on average. [Include brief quote comparison table.]

Remember, factors like your borough, driving record, and vehicle will impact your actual quotes. Get multiple quotes before selecting a provider.

Section 2 – Coverage Options

Most major auto insurers provide standard liability, collision, comprehensive, uninsured motorist coverage, etc. But a few have extras that may appeal to NYC drivers:

– MetLife offers enhanced rental reimbursement to fully cover a rental for up to 30 days. Helpful given limited personal parking.

– Progressive and Geico allow pay-per-mile policies, which can save money for limited drivers.

– Allstate offers rideshare coverage, important for Uber and Lyft drivers.

– State Farm has roadside assistance protection for breakdowns and flat tires.

Section 3 – Claims Satisfaction

If you do need to file a claim, you want the process to go smoothly. [J.D. Power data shows MetLife ranks highest in NYC customer satisfaction for claims experiences.]

Geico had below-average ratings, while Allstate had the most complaints according to the NY Department of Financial Services. Check reviews for details on local adjusters, repair shops, and response times.

Section 4 – Our Top Picks

While cost and claims should drive your choice, here are our recommended NYC providers:

– Single young driver – Progressive or Geico

– Experienced driver with a clean record – MetLife 

– Rideshare driver – Allstate


Comparing providers is the best way to find car insurance 2023 tailored to your needs and budget in NYC. Be sure to get quotes from several companies before deciding. And review policies regularly as new discounts arise and your situation changes.

By Hamisi

My name is Hamisi, the owner of Ajira Utumishi's blog. I have an experience in blogging since I can't remember. Read more about this blog on the about Us page. Welcome.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *